Sob, there are probably plenty of rowdy characters that want to be captain (as we can see!), so there'll probably be some fighting... But Tyr wouldn't mind trying to get everyone in order so they can get business done.

I was thinking that voting could even work like it's done in school clubs, where the candidates leave the room (and some can totally spy anyway) and the others just raise their hands to vote for whichever candidate they want. It's plausible and have several ways to go wrong!